There are all sorts of reasons why you might want to change your guitar tuning pegs. They might be worn out, hard to turn, and all-around has seen better days, or maybe you want a snazzier set to make more of a statement. Either way, you are going to need a set that actually does the job well.
Tuning pegs aren’t as simple as they look. Think about it this way, they are responsible for what sound comes from the guitar. That is a big deal! They work by creating tension on the guitar string so that once pulled, the string makes the desired musical note.
You may find that you have got to change your tuning pegs as often as every year and a half. The main reason being that tuning pegs cannot be fixed if they are damaged. Luckily for you guitarists, you won’t have to pay an arm and a leg these days for top-quality tuning peg, unless you want a vintage set, of course.
Read Related Article: Top 11 Best Tuning Forks for Healing
What To Look For When Buying Tuning Pegs
The first tip when buying replacement pegs is to make sure they are the right size for your guitar. If you fall in love with a set of special pegs that aren’t the perfect size, don’t worry, just take them to a guitar shop and they will custom install them for you. Be warned that this bumps up the overall price you will be paying for the pegs, in the end, so only do this if the pegs are really special.
Secondly, know the difference between friction pegs and gearing pegs. Friction pegs are more commonly used for orchestra instruments, and less with guitars. So don’t get confused and order friction pegs if that isn’t what your guitar requires. Gearing pegs are most probably what your guitar needs, but if you are unsure, ask for advice or research your guitar model.
In this review, we will be looking at 10 different friction pegs that are good specifically for guitars. This should help you weigh up what features are more important to you in a tuning peg, whether it is style, ease of use, or durability. One of the sets we are going to look at will be right for you.
|1. Metallor 3 on a Plank Guitar Tuning Pegs Plated Machine Heads Tuning Keys Tuners Single Hole for Classical Guitar
|2. AOMGD Guitar String Tuning Peg Tuner Machine Head
|3. YMC Chrome Tuning Peg
|4. Seismic Audio Set 4 Universal Black Tuning Peg
|5. Vangoa 3L3R 6 Pieces Guitar String Tuning Pegs for Acoustic or Electric Guitar, Chrome(Type A)
|6. ammoon Alice AOS-022V1P Acoustic Classical Guitar Machine Heads Tuning Keys Pegs String Tuners
|7.Gusnilo Style Tuning Pegs Grover Tuners Machine Heads Gold
|8. Musiclily Pro 3+3 Sealed Guitar Tuners Tuning Pegs Keys Machine Heads Set for Les Paul Style, Tulip Button Chrome
|9. Mr.Power Classical Guitar Tuners Machine Heads 3+3 Set Tuning Keys Machine Pegs(Black Button)
|10. Yibuy Gold Classical Guitar Pegs
Our 10 Best Guitar Tuning Pegs Reviews and Comparisons
1. Metallor 3 on a Plank Guitar Tuning Pegs Plated Machine Heads Tuning Keys Tuners Single Hole for Classical Guitar
Perfect if you have a classical guitar, these pegs look the part and do the job well.
- Comes in 5 sizes
- Chrome plated
- Plastic buttons
- Ideal for acoustic guitars
- Heavy duty internal gear
- 3 heads on one line
- 2 lines in a set
What We Like About Metallor Tuning Pegs
These pegs are super easy to install, especially if you get the perfect size for your guitar. The peg handles are also really sturdy, so tuning your guitar doesn’t take half as long to perfect. If you have measured your keyholes correctly, the size you choose will fit well.
What We Don’t Like About Metallor Tuning Pegs
The post covers are loose and fall off. Another issue is with the worm driver not touching the pioneer gear properly, which makes the gear almost impossible to turn. If you are not careful, the turning gear can snap while you attempt to tune your guitar.
- Beginners can install it
- Speeds up tuning time
- The size guide is accurate
- Looks good
- Loose post covers
- Gears and divers sometimes don’t match
2. AOMGD Guitar String Tuning Peg Tuner Machine Head
6 unconnected, individual machine heads.
- Gold, silver and white
- Made of metal and plastic
- High quality
- Tested product
What We Like About AOMGD Guitar String Tuning Peg
They give a plain guitar a really vintage, interesting look. Most importantly, they keep the guitar in tune for longer than other cheaper pegs.
What We Don’t Like About AOMGD Guitar String Tuning Peg
Overall, the pegs feel really flimsy, even though they manage to hold a tune or two. The screws aren’t that reliable either, maybe changing the screws would improve the quality a bit.
- Vintage looking
- Guitar stays tuned
- Not hard to install
- Fits acoustic guitars
- Pegs snap off
3.YMC Chrome Tuning Peg
New chrome tuning pegs with a heavy-duty internal gearing system.
- Pack of 6
- Includes 6 washers and 6 screws
What We Like About YMC Chrome Tuning Peg
The tuning ratio of these pegs is slower than the original, however, that is quite handy when it comes to fine-tuning your guitar. They don’t move on their own or lose tension quickly either.
What We Don’t Like About YMC Chrome Tuning Peg
Poor quality and prone to breaking while you tune your guitar. They don’t necessarily come apart from your instrument, but the peg will just stop tightening the string. Plastic pegs are less sturdy than metal ones and twist free.
- Easy to fine tune
- Don’t loosen
- Keep the guitar tuned for a while
- Easy to install
- Made cheaply
- Not sturdy
4. Seismic Audio Set 4 Universal Black Tuning Pegs
Set of 4 tuning pegs that come with all the installation equipment you need to do it yourself.
- 4 tuners (2 left 2 right)
- For bass guitars
- Sleek and dominant looking
What We Like About Seismic Audio Tuning Pegs
Black and striking, add a really attractive look to a bass guitar. Once you switch your old pegs out for these, you will notice a more sophisticated sound with a wider range of tones coming from the guitar.
What We Don’t Like About Seismic Audio Tuning Pegs
Tuning with the pegs isn’t smooth sailing. They give you the feeling that the pegs are going to give way at any given moment.
- Like original bass pegs
- Sounds great once tuned
- Easy to install
- Feel cheap
- Doesn’t turn smoothly
5. Vangoa 3L3R 6 Pieces Guitar String Tuning Pegs for Acoustic or Electric Guitar, Chrome(Type A)
Use these beautiful chrome pegs for tuning your acoustic or electric guitar.
- 15:1 ratio
- Sealed lubrication
- 6 total tuners (3 for left side, 3 for right side)
- Cast housings
- Includes mounting screws
What We Like About Vangoa 3L3R Tuning Pegs
Great for guitarists that are just starting to learn to play. If you like to make your own cigar box guitars you can use these pegs and they will work perfectly. You won’t have any trouble installing them yourself either.
What We Don’t Like About Vangoa 3L3R Tuning Pegs
The fit is very weird. You might even find one side will screw on perfectly and the other won’t at all. The only way to resolve this issue if it happens to you is by sending it to the guitar shop for proper fitting. Not all of the parts are metal either, as you may have wrongly assumed by looking at the pictures advertised.
- Fit homemade guitars
- Classy chrome finish
- Great for beginners
- Easy to install
- Plastic and rubber parts
- Don’t screw on well
6. ammoon Alice AOS-022V1P Acoustic Classical Guitar Machine Heads Tuning Keys Pegs String Tuners
These pegs suit a classic acoustic guitar. You get 6 pegs, which is a full set, with every order.
- 6 pegs
- 2 pack (3 left and 3 right pegs)
- Gold plated alloy panel
- Emboss pattern along the line
- Ratio of 1:16
What We Like About ammoon Alice AOS-022V1P Tuning Pegs
Beautiful black and gold color with an interesting pattern carved along each row. They make a really attractive addition to a classic guitar. Ready lubricated straight out of the factory, so you may not even have to grease before installation.
What We Don’t Like About ammoon Alice AOS-022V1P Tuning Pegs
There are only two color options available in this style. Some may find it a little bit fussy and out of place for a plain guitar. If you are not familiar with replacing this kind of tuning peg, it can be a little complicated to do and even time-consuming.
- Perfect for classic guitars
- Lubricated at the factory
- Jazz up an old guitar
- Easy to tune with
- Looks fussy
- Hard to install
7.Gusnilo Style Tuning Pegs Grover Tuners Machine Heads Gold
6 high-quality machine heads, 3 for the left, and 3 for the right hands’ side of your guitar.
- Zinc alloy and german metal pegs
- Heavy duty interior gear
- Includes 6 ferrules and 6 screws
What We Like About Gusnilo Style Tuning Pegs
If you have ever used a Grover deluxe tuner and loved it, these are extremely similar and almost just as good. They seem to hold the strings in place tightly and give a decent tune. They also look sleek and go with pretty much every guitar design out there without sticking out like a sore thumb.
What We Don’t Like About Gusnilo Style Tuning Pegs
If you aren’t familiar with tuning guitars, it may be a little hard for you to get the right notes and clarity. One thing that is a little frustrating is that it claims to fit all Taylor guitars, however, the peggs do not.
- Notes sound good
- Very similar to high end pegs
- Good quality
- Hard to tune with
- Doesn’t fit all guitars advertised
8. Musiclily Pro 3+3 Sealed Guitar Tuners Tuning Pegs Keys Machine Heads Set for Les Paul Style, Tulip Button Chrome
Tulip button-shaped 6 set tuning pegs.
- Fits Les Paul’s and many other similar guitars
- 10mm peghole diamiter
- Nut, ferrule and screws are included
- 3 left and 3 right turners
- Uniquely shaped
What We Like About Musiclily Pro 3+3 Sealed Guitar Tuners Tuning Peg
One of the best qualities these tuning pegs have is that they are not pitted. The metal feels heavy and is made of good quality. They are really compatible with Firefly guitars and will not need any professional adjustments made to fit Firefly’s and Les Paul’s models.
What We Don’t Like About Musiclily Pro 3+3 Sealed Guitar Tuners Tuning Peg
These are not made of Zeeno steel as advertised which is a little misleading. It also has a little bit of a ‘knock-off’ feel about the pegs, they are almost a good copy of high-end pegs but don’t quite make the cut.
- Great quality
- Compatible with many guitar brands
- Made of metal
- Chrome finish
- Look better than how they work
- Break easily
9. Mr.Power Classical Guitar Tuners Machine Heads 3+3 Set Tuning Keys Machine Pegs(Black Button)
Two rows of 3 pins for a classic or nylon string guitar.
- 6 pins
- Clamshell packaging
- 1:15 ratio
- Engraved metal
- Black and gold
What We Like About Mr.Power Classical Guitar Tuners
Some vintage guitars are difficult to get cog replacements for and even the best guitar shops don’t have a suitable replacement. These are a good option for vintage guitars. With a bit of tweaking, they fit really well.
If you measure your peg holes correctly and these are a match, they will slide in without any problem and take no time at all to install. Tightening the pegs and fine-tuning the guitar is really simple and smooth with these pegs.
What We Don’t Like About Mr.Power Classical Guitar Tuners
Where you would wind the string onto the tuner is unfortunately made entirely out of plastic. The pegs do not come lubricated and may need a bit of treatment before you put them on the guitar.
- Looks good
- Easy to install
- Tuning is made easy
- Works well overall
- Buttons made of cheap plastic
- Gear cogs do not always align with the turning mechanism
10. Yibuy Gold Classical Guitar Pegs
Three on a plank classic guitar tuning pegs.
- White and gold
- 6 pegs
- Right and left hand plank
- For classical guitars
What We Like About Yibuy Gold Classical Guitar Pegs
Tuning your guitar is surprisingly smooth, some guitars won’t even need to drill new holes to fit the planks.
What We Don’t Like About Yibuy Gold Classical Guitar Pegs
You must take extra care if you are going to install these yourself as it will most probably take a bit of adjusting and customizing to get it right.
- Easy to tune
- Suits vintage Yamahas
- Great value for money
- Replaceable buttons
- Color is not as advertised
- Overtightening will ruin your guitar wood
The ammoon Alice AOS-022V1P tuning pegs are the best pegs on the list. They are the least problematic out of all of the above tuning pegs and seem to last a while too. They add a quirky, vintage twist to any guitar, although looks are subjective and weren’t the main deciding factor of this review.
If you aren’t a massive fan of the way the ammoon Alice pegs look, or that they come in lines of three, the Gusnilo tuning pegs are in second place. The Gusnilo are a slightly different design, it comes with 6 individual pieces rather than 2, and is a much cleaner design.
How To Replace Guitar Tuning Pegs
Here is a really easy step by step guide to changing your pegs. Please note that some guitars will require additional steps so although these steps will work for most people, some will need to seek professional help.
1. Do your research to choose the most suited guitar tuning pegs for your guitar.
2. Before you start trying to take any bits and pieces off, unwind the strings from the guitar so that they don’t snap or hurt you.
3. Using a screwdriver, unscrew the tuning pegs carefully from the guitar neck.
4. Put the old pegs that still work in a safe place (you never know when you will need a spare).
5. Gently hammer out the jackets. Do this relatively gently so that you do not damage your guitar.
6. Grab your new guitar tuning pegs and separate them into ‘left’ and ‘right’ pegs. This is to avoid mixing them up and putting them on the wrong way.
7. Put the new jackets in. You may need to hammer them in if they do not slide in. (If you aren’t sure what to do at this stage, please go to the local guitar shop for assistance)
8. Screw the pegs onto the guitar.
9. Wind your strings back onto the guitar.
10. Tune your guitar and start making some music!
Older guitars may need extra care when changing the pegs as new pegs are made a little differently these days, so don’t drill any holes in the guitar neck if you’re not 100% confident in what you are doing.
Enjoy revamping your guitar and playing high quality music with your new tuning pegs. What pegs did you choose? We would love to hear back from you!